Tolstoy AI Alternatives for Shopify in 2027

The best Tolstoy alternative for a Shopify brand that wants an AI agent to answer shopper questions, sell and handle support is REP AI. Tolstoy has grown into a creative, ads and on-site AI platform, so the right alternative depends on which part of Tolstoy you actually use. This guide compares Tolstoy with REP AI, Tidio, Intercom Fin, Klaviyo Customer Agent and the Gorgias AI Agent on public prices and features, checked 20 Nov 2026.
Key takeaways
- Tolstoy's pricing page now lists Plus at $20 a month, Business at $100, $200 or $500 a month and custom Enterprise, with usage measured in AI credits and video viewers (as published on Tolstoy pricing page, checked 20 Nov 2026).
- If you mainly need shoppable video, creative production or virtual try-on, Tolstoy does things REP AI does not. REP AI does not make video or run try-on.
- If you mainly need an agent that answers pre-purchase questions, edits carts and resolves order issues, REP AI does that on your website, email, Instagram, Messenger and WhatsApp for $19 to $46 a month at up to 3,000 sessions.
- Credits, conversations, resolutions and sessions are different units. Compare them at your own volume before you switch.
- Prices for 2027 are unknown. Confirm current prices before you renew in 2027.
What does Tolstoy do today?
Tolstoy's current site describes a broad platform. It groups its products into Media Studio (product photos, videos and creator-style content), Ads Studio (ads and Meta campaigns) and Storefront Studio (shoppable video, virtual try-on and product advice). It also offers Shop Bots, which the site describes as AI agents you delegate work to, such as a Personal Shopper that helps shoppers choose and buy.
Its plan comparison lists on-site features including Ask AI, an AI search bar, chat bubble and embed, Sales Agents, Support Agents, product Q&A and a Brand MCP. Its integrations include Klaviyo, Gorgias, AfterShip and Loop Returns, and Instagram.
That is a wide set of tools. It is useful context for the decision, because many brands who search for a Tolstoy alternative want to replace only one piece of it.
What does Tolstoy cost?
As published on Tolstoy pricing page, checked 20 Nov 2026:
| Plan | Monthly price | Billed yearly | AI credits per month | Onsite AI credits | Video viewers per month |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plus | $20 | $16 | 4,000 | 1,000 | 5,000 |
| Business (3 usage levels) | $100 / $200 / $500 | $80 / $160 / $400 | 20,000 / 40,000 / 100,000 | 5,000 / 10,000 / 25,000 | 25,000 / 50,000 / 125,000 |
| Enterprise | Custom | Custom | Custom | Custom | Custom |
Tolstoy says Studio credits cover creation, workflows and Shop Bots, and that Onsite AI credits cover shopper conversations and virtual try-on. It also says different models and actions use different amounts, so credits are not a fixed number of photos, videos or conversations. Extra team members cost $20 per seat per month, and extra video viewers cost $10 per 1,000 on Plus and $7 or $5 per 1,000 on Business levels.
The practical point is that a credit pool shared between creative work and shopper chat is hard to turn into a monthly chat bill. Ask Tolstoy how many shopper conversations your Onsite AI credits cover for your store.
Why do Shopify brands look for a Tolstoy alternative?
These are questions to ask yourself. They are not faults in Tolstoy.
- You want a service agent first. If your biggest pain is order status, returns and exchanges, an agent built around support workflows and a helpdesk may fit better than a creative platform.
- You want a bill you can predict. A flat monthly price tied to site traffic is easier to forecast than credits that vary by model and action.
- You want more channels. If shoppers write by email, Instagram, Messenger or WhatsApp, check that the agent answers there with the same knowledge.
- You want sales and support in one agent. Separate tools for each create two sets of training and two places to fix a wrong answer.
Why is REP AI the Tolstoy alternative to pick for sales and support?
REP AI is an AI agent that sells and supports on Shopify. One agent handles both jobs, using your live catalog, orders and policies.
- Sales: proactive chat when a shopper hesitates, product recommendations from the live catalog, add to cart and edit the cart in chat, and discount codes in chat.
- Support: order status, returns and exchanges, cancellations, address changes, order modifications such as size or color, and damaged orders.
- Channels: website chat, email, Instagram, Facebook Messenger and WhatsApp. Shopify Markets gives local prices, currencies and languages.
- Helpdesk: Rep Inbox is REP AI's own helpdesk, and REP AI also hands off to helpdesks you already use with the full chat attached.
- Trust: SOC 2 Type II certified, with a 14-day free trial on every plan. It is on the Shopify App Store with 4.6 stars from 128 reviews.
What does REP AI cost?
Plans are priced by monthly website sessions. At up to 3,000 sessions, Support is $19, Sales is $39 and Concierge (sales and support together) is $46 a month. Billed yearly they are $15, $29 and $37 a month. At 80,000 sessions the monthly prices are Support $250, Sales $578 and Concierge $726. Stores above 500,000 sessions get custom pricing, and higher tiers are on the pricing page.
AI on email, Instagram, Facebook Messenger and WhatsApp is an add-on at $0.75 per AI-resolved conversation, or $0.50 on yearly billing. Overage is $1.20 per resolution, capped at a $1,000 reserve per billing cycle.
Where Tolstoy does more than REP AI
Be honest about scope. REP AI does not generate product photos, videos or ads, and it does not offer virtual try-on or shoppable video. If those are why you use Tolstoy, keep that need in mind. You can use a creative tool for content and REP AI for the conversation.
How do REP AI and the other Tolstoy alternatives compare?
All prices below are as published on each vendor's own pricing page, checked 20 Nov 2026. Units differ, so a lower number is not automatically a lower bill.
| Option | Built for | Pricing as published | Unit |
|---|---|---|---|
| REP AI | Selling and support on Shopify, one agent | Support $19, Sales $39, Concierge $46 a month at up to 3,000 sessions | Monthly website sessions, plus $0.75 per AI-resolved conversation on email and social add-on |
| Tolstoy | Creative, ads and on-site AI | Plus $20, Business $100 to $500 a month | AI credits and video viewers |
| Tidio | Live chat plus the Lyro AI agent | Starter with AI $33 a month billed annually for 50 conversations; Growth from $63 a month billed annually; Plus from $300 a month plus usage | Conversations (AI and human count together) |
| Intercom Fin | AI agent on the Intercom helpdesk | $0.99 per outcome; Intercom helpdesk Essential $19 per seat per month paid annually ($29 monthly) | Outcome plus seat |
| Klaviyo Customer Agent | Service agent tied to Klaviyo customer data | Page example of 1,000 AI resolutions a month at $700; free plan includes 10 resolutions a month | AI resolutions |
| Gorgias AI Agent | AI inside the Gorgias helpdesk | $1.00, $0.90 or $0.85 per automated interaction depending on plan, with plans from $40 a month | Automated interaction plus ticket tiers |
Sources: Tolstoy pricing, Tidio pricing, Intercom pricing, Klaviyo pricing and Klaviyo Customer Agent, Gorgias pricing, all checked 20 Nov 2026. The Gorgias figures are from the monthly billing view of its page.
How does each alternative differ from Tolstoy?
Tidio
Tidio combines live chat, a Flows builder and the Lyro AI agent. Its page lists native Shopify actions on the Growth plan and counts AI and human conversations against the same plan limit. It suits stores that want live chat and AI in one inexpensive tool. Check how its proactive messages are triggered and compare that with your own traffic.
Intercom Fin
Fin charges $0.99 per outcome, at most once per conversation, and refunds the outcome if the conversation is reopened, according to Intercom's pricing page. It sits on top of the Intercom helpdesk, so you pay seats as well. It fits teams that already run Intercom.
Klaviyo Customer Agent
Klaviyo's agent draws on Klaviyo customer data and hands off to Klaviyo Helpdesk. It fits brands that run their marketing in Klaviyo and want service in the same system. For a closer comparison, read Is Klaviyo's Customer Hub Enough as a Shopify Helpdesk in 2027?. REP AI also integrates with Klaviyo and syncs enriched profiles from conversations into it.
Gorgias AI Agent
Gorgias prices its AI Agent per automated interaction on top of ticket-based helpdesk plans. If you are weighing Gorgias against REP AI, our REP AI vs Gorgias comparison lays out both on public facts, and Gorgias alternatives covers the wider field.
How should you choose after leaving Tolstoy?
- List what you use. Write down which Tolstoy features your team used in the last 90 days: video, try-on, ads, shopper chat, support.
- Pull your volumes. Collect monthly sessions, chat conversations and tickets for a normal month and a peak month.
- Price the unit. Turn each quote into a monthly bill at your volumes. Our guide to AI chatbot pricing models shows how, and AI Customer Service Pricing in 2027 works the numbers.
- Test real questions. Ask each vendor's agent your ten hardest pre-purchase questions and your ten most common order problems.
- Run a trial. REP AI has a 14-day free trial on every plan, so you can judge it on your own conversations. See Best AI Shopping Assistant for Shopify in 2027 for what to test.
When you are ready to compare on your own catalog, book a demo or see pricing.
FAQ
What is the best alternative to Tolstoy for Shopify?
For an AI agent that sells and supports shoppers on your store, REP AI is the pick. It answers pre-purchase questions, edits the cart in chat and resolves order issues across website, email, Instagram, Messenger and WhatsApp. If you mainly need shoppable video or creative production, you are choosing a different kind of tool.
How much does Tolstoy cost in 2027?
Tolstoy's pricing page, checked 20 Nov 2026, lists Plus at $20 a month, Business at $100, $200 or $500 a month and custom Enterprise. We do not know 2027 prices, so confirm current prices before you renew in 2027.
Does REP AI replace Tolstoy's video features?
No. REP AI does not create video, ads or virtual try-on. It replaces the conversation layer: product questions, recommendations, cart actions and support.
Is Tidio a good Tolstoy alternative?
Tidio fits stores that want live chat and an AI agent in one tool. Its Starter plan with AI is $33 a month billed annually for 50 conversations, checked 20 Nov 2026. For proactive selling and support in one agent, REP AI is built for that job.
Can I try REP AI before cancelling Tolstoy?
Yes. Every REP AI plan has a 14-day free trial. Run it on your own catalog and compare the answers with your current setup before you decide.
Which AI customer service tool charges per resolution?
Intercom Fin charges $0.99 per outcome, Gorgias charges $0.85 to $1.00 per automated interaction and Klaviyo shows an example of $700 for 1,000 resolutions. REP AI prices core plans by monthly sessions, with a $0.75 per resolved conversation add-on for email and social channels.
More from REP AI
Want to see what your store would do with Rep?
Run your real Shopify catalog through the simulator before you commit to anything. No sales call required.



